***


WHO

FILM & TV

COMICS & BOOKS

INTERVIEWS

AMPHIGORY

MYSPACE

LIVEJOURNAL

FEED


*

HOME




Powered by FeedBlitz


Subscribe in Bloglines



Keep Miss de Campi
in the style to which
she has become
accustomed


9.11.04 The World Is Full of Angry People

The Wooster Collective is mad at me. Igor Kordey and I are both big fans of the British street artist Banksy, and we were inspired by two of his graffiti images for the covers of Issues 1 and 3 of SMOKE. These covers are currently in solicit form only, so without the series logo, publisher logo, or credits to anyone. We never tried to claim the images were not inspired by Banksy. We were going to credit the images on the cover as "After Banksy", and include a line on the first page of the comic where to go to check out Banksy's art. The folks at Wooster say we're stealing, and want us to drop or change the covers.

All we wanted to do was share our Banksy love, and do a credited homage. But apparently that's not on. Wooster seem quite determined that our intention was to do Banksy harm, but it most assuredly was not. We've emailed Banksy anyway, to ask his permission, and we'll see what he says.

Also, elsewhere on Wooster's site, they have works of art for sale at prices of $300 and up from their collective artists. These artists use well-known photos of Bruce Lee and James Dean, and images from the Spider-Man and Catwoman films. Whereas we changed Banksy's images significantly when we created the covers for SMOKE 1 and 3 (like I said, we used them for inspiration), the Spider-Man and Catwoman images are not changed in the slightest. They're simply direct copies. None of this use is credited, and I somehow don't think they got permission from the copyright holders. Photographers are artists too, folks. While I appreciate Wooster's efforts on Banksy's behalf, they do come across as a little bit hypocritical.

( 8:54 PM )

12 Comments:

AdC -- looks like you've been busy.
fuck 'em. These whining asses sound worse than Michael Moore on Nov 3rd

If anything, all their jibber-jabber is better pub for Banksy.... courtesy of YOU.

It sounds like the Wooster needs a {{hug}}

P burke

By Dell Aware, at 3:49 PM  

get a clue; plaigarism is plaigarism plain and simple. saying they do the same thing is neither here nor there. whether it's a photo or a piece of art, it's still stealing. i'd be interested to see the e-mail you get back from Banksy posted on this site....

i'm sure he'll have some words for you.

By Anonymous, at 9:37 PM  

i agree , "FUCK EM" they're sycophants. ok so you blatantly bit banksy. so what? - he is a cock knocker. live and learn.

By Anonymous, at 10:48 PM  

ripping off someone is weak, and making excuses for it after the fact is weak. if you'd boosted a pic of the mona lisa it might be different, but these pieces look like someone spent some time on them (while not being direct copies), plus the artist might be well known in some circles, but overall not that well known. trying to spin it in your favor by pointing out the flaws of someone else is especially weak and your unapologetic response to being called out is especially off-putting.

i won't be picking up smoke just out of sheer disgust. good job, one less customer to worry about.

By tstout, at 11:41 PM  

you may be appreciateing Banksy's work, but no offence the rendition is pretty poor and therefore casts Banksy's work in a bad light. you an artist..?

By Anonymous, at 9:45 AM  

you steal art tut tut,far to many people are allowed to get away with this, props to wooster collective for jumping on this.dont steal art its wrong.also i wont be buying your stuff anymore thats another customer gone,well done,and as for ..The World Is Full of Angry People.. well yea people do get angry when theives steal things,loosers get a grip.

By Anonymous, at 11:00 AM  

dont bite me.

By Anonymous, at 11:04 AM  

So, so lame.

You clearly don't care about your integrity as an 'artist', or you would have admitted to your blatant theft and saved some face rather than agrgue across your weak points.

What you have done is the equivalent of leaving a store with a basket of goods, and then saying "I was gonna go back and pay for them".

Admit it- You had no intentions of mentioning Banksy at all- Because you didn't do your resrearch properly and figured he was some small-fry kid. Well guess what- You're wrong- And now everyone can see how weak your ideas are.

By Anonymous, at 11:08 AM  

the difference between your work and the wooster collective's work you mentioned is creativity. you may have changed the image but still the concept remains the same... there's nothing wrong with using images from former artworks as long as you create a new artwork, not a cheesy rip-off.

mentioning the phrase "inspired by" is not an excuse for stealing this creativity.
just keep doing your thing.
m

By miro, at 11:19 AM  

Email from Chris to the Wooster Collective (~Nov. 9.):

"Until today, I hadn't even heard of Banksy, so for you to say we knew he'd shut us down if we asked about emulating his work is ludicrous."

Hahahaha!

By clintonclintonclinton, at 1:59 PM  

taking a Bruce Lee photo and placing it against a red background is art? Who knew?

By little*ragamuffin, at 4:07 PM  

Essentially the way I see things is the Wooster Collectives sale of Hollywood posters is akin to DJ Dangermouse's mashup album of Jay Z vs. the Beatles. He took two well-known works, and made something new out of them. Most DJ's take work that is not theirs and they are still credited as artists by the public at large.

What I consider "smoke" to be doing is more akin to Puff Daddy, or Vanilla ice. What they’re doing is not even a cover song, or a remixed version, they took an original work, spruced it up a bit, slapped their name on it, and sold it to the public as something new, making massive amounts of money in the process. Sure they used some artistic talent to do it, but really they’ve added nothing, and created nothing.

Calling it an homage, is an excuse to exploit someone else’s work. An homage should celebrate the persons original work, this is not an homage, its a reproduction. Saying they were inspired by banksy is also an excuse, because being inspired by a work should influence your work in subtle ways, I’m inspired by most of the artists on Wooster collectives site, and yet my work looks like none of theirs.

Pointing the finger back at Wooster by saying they are hypocritical by selling remixed versions of Hollywood posters is the same as calling Warhol a thief and a hypocrite for his use of a Campbell’s soup can.

By skrike, at 5:51 PM  

Post a Comment


SYNDICATION: LiveJournal

ARCHIVES: October 2004 November 2004 December 2004 January 2005 February 2005 March 2005 April 2005 May 2005 June 2005 July 2005 August 2005 September 2005 October 2005 November 2005 December 2005 January 2006 February 2006 March 2006 April 2006 May 2006 June 2006 July 2006 August 2006 September 2006 October 2006 November 2006 December 2006 January 2007 February 2007 March 2007 April 2007 May 2007


& FOR HER NEXT TRICKS:

Kat & Mouse 2 cover

KAT & MOUSE 2
January 2007
ISBN-10: 1598165496
$5.99 / All Ages

Messiah Complex cover

AGENT BOO 2
January 2007
ISBN-10: 1598168037
$4.99 / All Ages

***

RECENTLY:

Messiah Complex cover

MESSIAH COMPLEX 1
October 2006
ISBN-10: 2731617667
EUR12,90 / Teen

Agent Boo cover

AGENT BOO 1
Sept 2006
ISBN-10: 1598168029
ISBN-13: 9781598168020
$4.99 / All Ages

Kat & Mouse cover

KAT & MOUSE 1
July 2006
ISBN-10: 1598165488
ISBN-13: 9781598165487
$5.99 / All Ages

Smoke cover

SMOKE
December 2005
ISBN-10: 193323928X
$24.99 / Teen

***

Brief Loves:
Music: Berlin Cabaret Songs
Film: Chetyre (4)
Book: Camera Lucida

***

Friends & Conspirators:
Kieron Gillen
Alasdair Watson
Evil Genius
Paul O'Brien
Jonny Nagl
Chad Michael Ward
The Graf von Sarll
Delirium des Anges
Jeremy Love
Frazer Irving
Antony Johnston
Tristan Crane
Laurenn McCubbin
Dan Evans
Farel Dalrymple
Brendan McFeely
Warren Ellis
Dean Haspiel
Brian Wood
Igor Kordey
Kelly Sue DeConnick
Flipron
Tiny Dog Records

Admired Strangers:
Bob Mould
Popbitch
Revenant Records
Grand Central Records
Tom Phillips
The Starn Brothers
The Real Tuesday Weld
Misty's Big Adventure
The Earlies
Menlo Park
Akira the Don
Coop

***

Musical Exotica:
Planet Xtabay
Poison To The Mind